Introduction
When renewing your car insurance, the common question pops up of which coverage type should we buy either comprehensive or third party? The only proper way to choose is by first analyzing your vehicle from the age and value. By understanding those 2 criteria, you can base your choosing on what your coverage needs actually are. In this article, will explain the key difference between comprehensive and third party and choose which is best for your car.
Quick Comparison Table
| Factor | Comprehensive Insurance | Third Party Insurance |
| Coverage | Own damage, theft, fire, natural disasters + third party | Third party injury & property damage only |
| Best For | New cars, high-value cars, financed vehicles | Older cars, low-value cars, limited budget |
| Premium | Higher, but wide coverage | Lower, but very limited |
| Repair Costs | Covered by insurer (if claim is valid) | Borne by owner |
| Add-ons | Windscreen, flood, roadside assist | Rare |
| Peace of Mind | High | Low |
What is Comprehensive Insurance?
Comprehensive insurance provides the broadest protection. It not only covers third party liabilities but also protects your own car against:
- Accidents
- Theft
- Fire
- Natural disasters (with add-ons)
If your car is still under loan, banks usually require comprehensive coverage. It’s ideal for anyone who wants maximum peace of mind.
What is Third Party Insurance?
Third party insurance is the minimum legal requirement in Malaysia. It covers:
- Injuries or death caused to others
- Damage to other people’s vehicles or property
But it does not cover your own car at all. That means repair costs fall on you. While cheaper, it offers limited financial protection.
Which Suits New Cars Best?
For new or high-value cars, comprehensive insurance is the smarter option.
- Protects against costly repairs.
- Required by banks for financed vehicles.
- Helps safeguard your car’s high resale value.
Verdict: Comprehensive suits new cars.
Which Suits Old Cars Best?
For older cars (10 years and above), paying for comprehensive may not be worth it.
- Premiums may cost more than the car’s market value.
- Third party keeps you road-legal at a lower price.
- Suitable for rarely used or secondary cars.
Verdict: Third party suits old cars.
FAQs
1. Can I switch from comprehensive to third party?
Yes, especially once your car loan is settled and your car is older.
2. Is comprehensive compulsory?
Only if your car is under financing. Otherwise, it’s optional.
3. Does third party cover my passengers?
No, it only covers the other party involved in an accident.
4. When should I downgrade to third party?
When your car’s value drops below RM10,000 or when it’s over 10 years old.
Conclusion
Choosing between comprehensive or third party all depends on your car’s status be it for the value,age and budget. For newer cars, comprehensive is the best choice. For old cars, third party is often more practical and affordable. In the end, choosing the perfect plan that fits your budget and has adequate coverage depends on your choice.
Read More:
5 Common Road Offences That Often Get You Fined by JPJ
