Introduction
Many drivers in Malaysia know about car insurance, but not everyone understands the difference compared to car Takaful. Some choose based on price, while others prioritise Shariah compliance. To avoid confusion, let’s take a closer look at the comparison between car insurance and car Takaful, including their strengths and weaknesses.
Comparison: Car Insurance vs Takaful
| Aspect | Car Insurance (Conventional) | Car Takaful |
| Principle | Contract between company & car owner, based on risk and profit | Mutual protection concept (risk-sharing) under Shariah |
| Returns / Surplus | Premiums belong fully to the insurance company | Surplus (if any) can be redistributed to participants |
| Shariah Compliance | Not Shariah-compliant | 100% Shariah-compliant |
| Premium Price | Depends on insurer & coverage type | Sometimes slightly different, but still competitive |
| Popularity | Established and widely used | Increasingly popular among Muslim drivers |
Advantages of Car Insurance
- Many established and new companies to choose from
- More flexibility in protection packages
- Sometimes offer aggressive promotions, cashback, or discounts
Advantages of Car Takaful
- Fully Shariah-compliant (no riba/gharar)
- Surplus can be redistributed to participants
- Seen as fairer due to the risk-sharing model
So, Which One Is More Suitable?
- If you prioritise the most competitive pricing, conventional insurance offers more options.
- If you value Shariah compliance and the concept of shared responsibility, car Takaful may be the better choice.
- Both are fully legal in Malaysia and can be purchased/renewed through online platforms like Bjak, MyEG, or directly at JPJ/MyJPJ.
Conclusion
When it comes down to which type of insurance you need, be it protection needs for conventional car insurance or principled base like Takaful, it really all depends on your budget and coverage which is needed most and more suited to your current situation. But whatever your choice may be, always compare prices before making any decision on purchases to make sure you’re getting the best protection at a reasonable price.
Read More:
Soalan Lazim Roadtax Kereta Digital (JPJ e-LKM)
